In August of 2025 Auburn University garnered the attention of the college football world by claiming additional national titles for their football program. The school will now claim nine football championships while previously only celebrating one in 1957. Auburn is not alone, each school across the country takes different avenues to claim national championships.
Notre Dame leans on what is considered consensus national football championships and has earned 11 total titles in 1924, 1929, 1930, 1943, 1946, 1947, 1949, 1966, 1973, 1977 and 1988. Even that definition of ‘consensus’ is strained, however, because the NCAA only recognizes ‘consensus’ titles since 1950 and since that season – 74 years – the ‘consensus’ national title has been shared 17 times.
The Irish have been involved in three of those shared ‘consensus’ titles, 1964, 1966 and 1973. As you can see from the list in the previous paragraph, Notre Dame doesn’t even consider it won a title in 1964 but there were recognized selectors who did.
The question gets asked many times. If Notre Dame claimed national titles like (insert a school name of your choice here) how many national titles would they have? The University is not taking any steps toward claiming more titles, but there is nothing wrong with attempting to try to answer that question that many Fighting Irish football fans ponder from time to time.
A simple answer is that there are 11 other seasons in which a selector, recognized by the NCAA football record book, named Notre Dame the national champion. Those seasons are 1919, 1920, 1927, 1938, 1953, 1964, 1967, 1970, 1889, 1993 and 2012. There are arguments to be made that Notre Dame also could make a case for the 1941 and 1948 seasons. That is 13 more additional titles.
Are any of them legitimate? Let’s dive in and work our way up from what would be perceived as the weakest arguments for a season to what might be something that, in the future, Notre Dame might consider adding to their national championship total.
For the sake of the analysis moving forward, all rankings referred to will be the Associated Press, which began in 1936 and is the longest running and most consistent ranking system recognized in college football.
Rating System:
🏆 - Selected by a recognized national championship outlet listed in the NCAA records book, but the data, or any argument for that season, does not meet legitimate national championship criteria.
🏆🏆 - In the early years of college football when travel was an incredible challenge and Notre Dame had a hard time filling its schedule, it was difficult to claim a national championship but not impossible. For later dates, it is a special season that would most likely show up on title lists claimed by other programs.
🏆🏆🏆 - A strong case that some day should be considered to add to the official list.
🏆🏆🏆🏆 - If Notre Dame was ever going to claim additional national titles, this is one of the years that they should.
National Championship Selectors: 🔢 for mathematical based selections, 🗳️ for voting-based selections.
